Have Lucky Charms cereal milk in your bowl? Save it to make cereal milk pudding cookie cups. Made with vanilla pudding, sugar cookies, and marshmallows.
Today’s recipe is pretty simple once you get past the sorting of the Lucky Charms cereal from the marshmallows. Otherwise, you’re mostly using pre-made and semi-made ingredients.
What you need to make cereal milk pudding cookie cups:
- Lucky Charms cereal, sorted
- Milk
- Instant vanilla pudding
- Sugar cookie dough
- Green food coloring, optional
Before making the pudding, I soaked just the cereal in the milk while the sugar cookie cups baked. After straining out the cereal milk, it was then used to made cereal milk pudding. Dye it green if you want to be festive or leave it as is because those marshmallows you sorted out will be used as the decorative topping.
In case you don’t want to just eat the remaining Lucky Charms you can also use it to make lucky buckeye cookies, lucky lemon pie, lucky cheesecake bars, lucky seven layer bars, or even lucky crispy treats.
Three years ago: Corned Beef Nachos with Beer Cheese Sauce
Four years ago: How to Regrow Green Onions #ScienceSundays
Six years ago: Matcha Rice Crispy Treats
Nine years ago: Salted Caramel Double Chocolate Stout Cookies
Eleven years ago: St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Roundup (2014)
Twelve years ago: Cheesy Chicken Quesadilla Pie
Thirteen years ago: Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza
Fourteen years ago: Apple Harvest Oatmeal
Source: Adapted from my Funfetti Pudding Sugar Cookie Cups.
