Heart-Shaped Reese’s Stuffed Cookie for Two

2.1K

The way to a peanut butter lover’s heart is this Heart-Shaped Reese’s Stuffed Cookie for Two. Share with your loved one or treat yourself!

Jump to recipe

I first shared the recipe for this Heart-Shaped Reese’s Stuffed Cookie for Two 10 years ago, but it was combined with another recipe in the same post. Oh those joyous days when we didn’t have all of these Google SEO rules to follow and posted with abandon. But I digress.

While going through recipes to update for Valentine’s Day, I decided it was time to revisit the trend of reese’s stuffed cookies, but just for two. It would appear that peanut butter cups and love are synonymous in my brain as I’ve already shared two other festive recipes this year including reese’s cookie bars and peanut butter cup brownies. But is there such a thing as too many peanut butter cups?

I also thought it was a fun ode to the fact that 10 years ago my husband, then boyfriend, and I made those two recipes together. Since Valentine’s Day lands on a weekday we cooked this same meal together again: sun-dried tomato ravioli, roasted brussels sprouts, white wine, and a Heart-Shaped Reese’s Stuffed Cookie of course!

This recipe would normally made a single serving cookie but the addition of a 5 oz. peanut butter cup inside considerably beefs up this Reese’s Stuffed Cookie to two servings. Even more so when served warm topped with ice cream. Or eat the entire thing yourself, no judgement.

Should you chill the Reese’s stuffed cookie dough before baking?

If you are looking to prep ahead of time, in order to simply pop this in the oven when ready, you definitely can. However, unlike drop cookies, this Reese’s Stuffed Cookie doesn’t require chilling. Since it is baked in a container it eliminates the worry of excessive spreading which chilling would normally help combat.

If you’re like me and want all the peanut butter cups for Valentine’s Day you should also consider making my Lunch Lady reese’s pieces peanut butter cookies, chocolate reese’s pieces cookies if you prefer more chocolate, or even a reese’s cookie cake for a larger celebration.

We are fundraising for pediatric cancer research funds again! This is the seventh annual Good Cookies Valentine’s Event! I’m thrilled to be participating again to help make a difference in the fight against pediatric cancer research. My food blogger and content creator friends got together again and we are sharing Valentine’s Day inspired recipes to inspire you to cook and to share and donate to Cookies for Kids’ Cancer. Did you know that cancer is the #1 cause of death of children by disease in the U.S? And that childhood cancer survivors often have long term effects, more than ⅔ of them develop secondary cancers, heart disease, kidney disease and others. There are 40,000 U.S. children actively battling cancer right now. We would love your help to get the word out about how much childhood cancers affect a lot of us. A lot of us know someone who has been affected. Let’s help make these families lives a little bit better. Please help spread the word and if you can, please donate today to Cookies for Kids’ Cancer! Our goal is to raise at least $3000. Because Mediavine has pledged to match our donations raised through this campaign up to $3000! That means your donation will be doubled! Thank you to so many of you who have already donated, please help us reach our goal so we can get the full matching donations and help us make an even huge difference! Donate here today. We have until March 31st to raise $3000! So please donate today! Heart-Shaped Homemade Pop Tarts from Julie of The Little Kitchen Valentine Cupid Crunch from Jenn of Ever After in the Woods Easy Dark Chocolate Cherry Truffles from Audrey of That Recipe How to Make an Edible Valentine Gingerbread House from Jennifer of The Rebel Chick Peanut Butter Chocolate Parfaits from Stefanie of Stef’s Eats and Sweets Heart Shaped Chocolate Chip Cookies from Melissa of Persnickety Plates Valentine Ladybug Oreos from Jaclyn of Crayons & Cravings Round Up of Homemade Valentine’s Day Sweets and Treats from Lisa of Blogghetti Mini skillet cookie from Caroline of Caroline’s Cooking Easy Pink Cookie Recipe (Refined Sugar-free) from Shashi of Savory Spin Truffle Honey Goat Cheese Stuffed Rolls from Lisa of Taste Cook Sip Sweetheart Strawberry Brownies from Nicole of For the Love of Food Heart Shaped Pancakes from Sarah of TheGleasonCo Chubby Hubby Cookies from Rebecca of Sugar & Soul How to Make an Edible Valentine Gingerbread House from Jennifer of The Rebel Chick Heart-Melting Chocolate Espresso Cookies from Colleen of Faith, Hope, Love, & Luck Survive Despite a Whiskered Accomplice

Source: Adapted from Bake Your Day (website no longer active), originally posted in the same post as my Sun-Dried Tomato Ravioli with Basil Cream Sauce.

Did you make this recipe? I want to see! Tag @THESPIFFYCOOKIE on Instagram and hashtag it #THESPIFFYCOOKIE

Recipe separated from a combination post originally shared on 2/14/2013, photo above is the original.

This content contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.